There has been much hullabaloo in Austin about those so-called rolling blackouts we had across the state of Texas on the coldest day of winter (in fact, several winters). I imagine there’s been much hullabaloo about it in cities across the state. Few things get citizens’ panties in a wad than being without heating during winter, especially when it is discovered only some suffered while others didn’t. Can’t very well expect human beings to sit in their freezing cold homes for a whole day without getting cranky! Can’t very well expect said human beings to just get over it either, especially when every public announcement on the matter only makes the powers-that-be in charge of our power look even worse.
ERCOT, the electrical system’s regulatory group, has admitted they could have done a better job of communicating with the public and with local power companies. It has also been admitted the reason for the lack of adequate power to run our entire state was caused by the gross negligence of power plant operators who –for reasons completely unknown– failed to properly prepare for the extreme cold front we all knew was headed our way (causing plants to go down due to ridiculous things like broken water pipes or frozen gauges). All parties involved have sworn to do better in the future, but I’ll believe it when I see it … in the form of not ever sitting in my home freezing my butt off for an entire day, all because I happen to live in an expendable neighborhood.
On a more local level, Austin Energy, who has also been taking some heat for the fact the blackouts were exclusively focused on a small number of neighborhoods, is also crying mea maxima culpa, and they are coming up with ideas to avoid having residents wanting their heads on a silver platter in the future. Unfortunately, as is usually the case, their ideas to make things right never seem to extend to residents and only to businesses.
Weis said the utility would look for ways to spread the outages more evenly. For instance, he said, “We’re gonna look at whether … we can make arrangements with customers to be a part” of the blackouts voluntarily, perhaps by shutting off their own power. Under that scenario, Austin Energy would negotiate some sort of deal to pay such a customer to keep the lights off during an outage.
Alternatively, the utility could offer a discounted monthly rate to customers on the circuits most likely to be shut down during rolling outages.
Weis said the idea would be difficult to extend to homes because “you’d need a lot of them to make a difference with the amounts of power we’re talking about, and it would be very complicated.”
When he says “customers” he means businesses. Apparently, I –being just a lowly human being living in a home that uses electricity which I pay Austin Energy to use– am not actually a customer. Silly me for ever thinking otherwise, right? But what I want to focus on is the bit I highlighted in bold. Seems to me we know how many homes it takes to make a difference. It takes as many homes as were without power for an entire day on that fateful, cold day of rolling blackouts. They already know which circuits they cut, and they know they will use these same circuits again in the future, if the need arises. There is no great mystery about how many circuits need to go down in order to save the grid or who will be the ones sitting at home freezing their butts off. Sure, some smaller businesses get caught up in that too, but they certainly didn’t cut power to Dell even though it was in a circuit that could have been shut down, because (as they stated) that would have cost Dell downtime and money. So their plan is to provide incentives and retribution for businesses who might have their power involved in rolling blackouts in the future, but screw the working man … or woman, as it may be.
Furthermore, at no small expense to Austin Energy’s customers, fancy new meters were installed a few years ago that communicate instantly with the power company. It’s no longer actually required for me to call them to tell them my power is out (or so they say), because as soon as the power goes out, my super-intelligent meter informs them my home –my exact home– is without power. It also informs them on a very regular, multiple times a day (possibly as low as every 15 minutes) of my exact energy usage (ending the need for meter readers and allowing the energy company to charge me premium rates for my energy usage during high demand periods). For Austin Energy to pretend the two-way communication provided by the mesh network between the power company and the smart meters on homes won’t allow them to make a similar offer of reduced rates or other incentives to humans in homes that they would like to offer to businesses is, in a word, bullshit.
If they can discern between business accounts that have and have not bought into their rolling blackout incentive plan, they can surely also do the same for homes in those 44 effected circuits. Why am I any less important than the restaurant or convenience store down the road? My residential account pays more per kilowatt hour for energy than does a commercial account (though, of course, we use less), and without the residential customers in those 44 circuits, they’d certainly be whining about a loss of revenue. The fact they insist they just can’t possibly come up with a way to make residential customers happy with their service as well (most notably those of us who now know we will always be on the chopping block first) is a loud and clear message to those of us who suffered through that cold day with no heat of exactly where we stand on the ladder. We don’t. We’ll be pushed off at the first sign of a power crisis without so much as a “Sorry! Thank you! Have a fiver for your trouble!”
Yes, I am still cranky about this issue. No one likes to be made to feel they are utterly expendable and completely unimportant, and that’s how I have been made to feel –like I have to make the sacrifice for the greater good without being asked my opinion on the matter or being in some way stroked or compensated for doing so, while paying them for the pleasure. It’s not me making a sacrifice. It’s my home and all the others on those 44 circuits being sacrificed. Tossed into the volcano to appease the angry energy gods. That said sacrifice was necessary due to negligence and incompetence is really just the icing on the crappy cake. I have a right to be cranky about that.
And this brings me to another sore point, though it is one that doesn’t (yet) affect me personally. I’m a middle-aged woman in decent enough health, and being without electricity for a day and feeling cold isn’t going to immediately do me any great harm. Oh, it’s unpleasant to be sure, but health-wise, it likely won’t kill me. What about people like my dad who had to have supplemental oxygen created by an electrically powered machine and required drugs dispensed by an electrically powered machine? His emergency tank of oxygen would have lasted 3-4 hours, and then what? He’d have had to go to the emergency room in order to breath and continue living. What about other ill persons using all manner of electrically powered machines in their homes to maintain their health (if not their very lives)? What about home-bound senior citizens who are very prone to feeling the effects of the cold and who are incapable of leaving their homes to seek somewhere warmer to wait it out? What about the weakest among us?
I haven’t heart anyone talking about this particular angle of the rolling blackouts. The sick and the elderly (and the sick elderly most especially) can die quite quickly from a lack of electricity for medical devices and/or the lack of heating/cooling. Some of them are literally trapped in their homes, incapable of leaving without assistance. Had I not had an all-gas stove with which to supply some warmth in my home, I would have had to abandon it by noon. The outside and inside temperatures were quickly equalizing, and the ten minutes an hour of power I was receiving did nothing to change that. In fact, those ten minutes every hour really just seemed like a cruel joke. Here, have some power… HA HA! NOT! It gave the furnace just enough time to realize it needed to turn itself on, to fire up the heaters and blowers and start blowing heat, and then no more power. Also gave me just enough time for the cable box to reboot, the TV to come on, and for me to get a few minutes of news and weather. If I was wearing every piece of warm clothing I had and was huddled by the open oven door by late afternoon, how do you think the sick and elderly, many who will not have all-gas stoves or all gas heat, fared under those conditions? I’m guessing not well, yet no one is talking about it, which leads me to believe no one really cares very much.
This is another point where their lack of good communication skills comes into play. The sick and elderly –and those who love them– can make other arrangements for their care and comfort if they know what’s going on. Between listening to the radio, catching what local TV news I could, and my (somewhat limited) connection to the internet through my cell phone, it was well into afternoon that day before I knew what was going on … that the blackouts were not only planned but targeted to specific neighborhoods. Now, I’m a smart girl, and I’d already noticed the pattern of ten minutes on and fifty minutes off earlier in the day and suspected the blackouts were not a normal foul weather grid malfunction. I definitely sensed an intelligence (snort) behind it. Simply not random enough to be anything other than intentional. Even the people I know locally who were not suffering blackout conditions couldn’t tell me what was going on, because no one was saying anything about it other than that Texas was having a power crisis. With all my ability to receive information, I still didn’t know what was going on and how long it might last. Now imagine I was someone less connected, sick or elderly or both, and sitting in a house that is growing colder and has been dark more than not. How do I decide or know I need to seek warmer shelter elsewhere or proceed to the hospital? Why wouldn’t I think “The power is trying to come back on. I’m sure it’ll come back on for good any minute now!” even though the truth was that it wouldn’t be coming back on for good at any minute. It was going to be more off than on for the day (and I hear in some cases more than a day).
I don’t know how ERCOT and Austin Energy is going to solve the problem of better communication (though they knew days in advance these rolling blackouts might be necessary – so maybe just freaking announcing it immediately on all news sources would be a good start) or how they can make things right for those of us who are slated to always be on the chopping block first during an energy crisis, but they better figure out something. I don’t mind being asked to sacrifice my own comfort for the greater good (for a limited time) when absolutely necessary, but I would like to be ASKED or –at the very least– be made to feel like I am worth asking and making nice with after the fact. They know the meter ID of every meter in every circuit that has and will again be subject to rolling blackouts, and something needs to be done to communicate better with those persons (and businesses) and to make sure we don’t feel like virgins being fed to the dragon just for living in the wrong zip code.
And the next time I’m sitting in my home with ten minutes of power out of every sixty and either freezing or being baked (this could happen during the summer as well, when our electrical usage is even higher), I believe I will start a Twitter campaign t o get everyone likewise suffering rolling blackouts to meet up at the Dell lobby, where I hear the temperature is guaranteed to always be perfect for human life forms and the power will never fail.